History & Classics

Presenter Information

Molly Nebiolo, Butler University

Document Type

Poster Presentation

Location

Indianapolis, IN

Subject Area

History & Classics

Start Date

11-4-2014 12:00 PM

End Date

11-4-2014 1:00 PM

Description

Medical history has recently been growing as a field of study because of the strong advancements occurring in medicine. Many have studied the progression of modern medicine from Ancient History through to the Renaissance, but little attention has been given to the true effectiveness of medicine right before it was transformed within the 16th and 17th centuries. In analyzing the success of European medieval medicine on the patient, we can start to understand the evolution of healing since the first recitings of the Hippocratic Oath. Through the use of popular texts like Stere Htt Well, The Mirror of Jaume Roig, and The Medieval Women's Guide to Health, this research will try to decipher whether the learned physicians or the common healers in the medieval ages had the most effective practices towards healing. The thoughts of other historians are split between whether or not the practices (religion, astrology, humorism, and midwifery) were actually helpful for the ill. It is through the documented opinions of the patient for us to find the truth. Although it is difficult to know whether or not the judgments from patients have been altered by bias, there are still efforts being made to find the true opinions hidden in the contracts that still survive. Sadly, many of these voices cannot be recaptured. With the Bolognese contracts used in this argument along with the texts mentioned above, I propose that both the learned and the common healers had effective practices for healing the sick.

Share

COinS
 
Apr 11th, 12:00 PM Apr 11th, 1:00 PM

Charms, Prayers, Concoctions, and Pilgrimages: The Effectiveness of Learned Medicine versus Common Medicine During the Medieval Ages

Indianapolis, IN

Medical history has recently been growing as a field of study because of the strong advancements occurring in medicine. Many have studied the progression of modern medicine from Ancient History through to the Renaissance, but little attention has been given to the true effectiveness of medicine right before it was transformed within the 16th and 17th centuries. In analyzing the success of European medieval medicine on the patient, we can start to understand the evolution of healing since the first recitings of the Hippocratic Oath. Through the use of popular texts like Stere Htt Well, The Mirror of Jaume Roig, and The Medieval Women's Guide to Health, this research will try to decipher whether the learned physicians or the common healers in the medieval ages had the most effective practices towards healing. The thoughts of other historians are split between whether or not the practices (religion, astrology, humorism, and midwifery) were actually helpful for the ill. It is through the documented opinions of the patient for us to find the truth. Although it is difficult to know whether or not the judgments from patients have been altered by bias, there are still efforts being made to find the true opinions hidden in the contracts that still survive. Sadly, many of these voices cannot be recaptured. With the Bolognese contracts used in this argument along with the texts mentioned above, I propose that both the learned and the common healers had effective practices for healing the sick.